VAT Registration Is Costing Me Money: A Case Study

Registering for VAT is a big step for any business. While some are forced into it because their turnover has exceeded the threshold for compulsory registration, others choose to register of their own accord. Most business owners think this through extensively before coming to a decision; others, though, presume that VAT Registration is simply ‘the done thing’ and, as a result, rush into it.

Before making any VAT decisions, it's worth understanding which aspects of your business might attract HMRC scrutiny using our free HMRC Red Flag Checker.

This case study concerns a business owner who thought carefully about VAT registration. Having looked back at her previous six months’ records, she decided that her input tax (that is, the money she paid out to suppliers in VAT) was greater than what she would have charged in output tax (that is, the amount she would have charged in VAT during that period).

“It seemed like a good idea. Had my trading patterns stayed the same, I would have been able to continue claiming a rebate on VAT most months,” she said. “As it is, I’m quite severely out of pocket and considering deregistration.”

Tax Investigations

The woman runs a small, specialist retail business in which she adapts costume jewellery and sells it on. She registered for VAT and, as her input tax exceeded her output tax, she claimed a rebate for the first VAT period. “This is really where the problems started,” she said. “The taxman launched an investigation almost immediately.”

All businesses must be prepared for a tax inspection, but there seems to be evidence that HM Revenue & Customs (HMRC) is particularly suspicious of firms and individuals that register for VAT and then immediately claim a rebate.

Although the investigation found that the relevant records were in order, the process took a significant chunk out of the woman’s schedule. “The investigation took about two weeks. I run the business entirely on my own, and I just couldn’t afford to take that much time out.”

Self Assessment Helper

Confused by self assessment? Tell us about your income and circumstances and get a clear guide to what you need to declare, what you can claim, and the key deadlines.

Try our Self Assessment Helper free, here on this site →

Price Discrepancies

Undeterred, the woman continued claiming back VAT on a regular basis. But, after eight months’ trading, the recession hit and she began dropping her prices in a bid to stay competitive. “It actually worked better than expected, in that my sales volumes skyrocketed. I ended up being much more efficient, and using fewer materials.”

While this was good for her bottom line, it had a disastrous impact on her VAT situation. For the first time, her input tax fell as she had to buy fewer materials, and as her suppliers dropped their prices. At the same time, though, her output tax was increasing as she sold more products.

Your situation may be slightly different. ask a question below ↓ and our editorial team will reply with our advice.

Deregistration

Although the woman in question thought through her decision carefully, and has been affected by circumstances outside her control, hers is a cautionary tale for all business owners considering VAT registration. While many businesses may see a positive effect from registration, the potential dangers are not to be ignored. Make sure that you Seek Advice From An Accountant before registering, in order to be confident that you are doing the right thing for your business.

The Next Step

Now that you have read through the advice above, you might want to put it into practice. Our Self Assessment Helper lets you confused by self assessment? Tell us about your income and circumstances and get a clear guide to what you need to declare, what you can claim, and the key deadlines. Try it now →